Share
Choosing a golf launch monitor often boils down to one fundamental question: should you go with radar or camera (photometric) technology? Both have distinct advantages and ideal use cases, and understanding these differences is key to making the right investment for your practice environment.
Radar-Based Launch Monitors: The Open-Air Specialists
How they work: Radar-based systems, like those used by Trackman, use Doppler radar to emit microwave signals that bounce off the golf ball (and sometimes the club). By analyzing the frequency shifts of these returning signals, the device can precisely measure speed, launch angle, spin rates, and ball flight trajectory over a long distance.
Pros:
-
Exceptional for Outdoor Use: Radar truly shines outdoors, tracking the entire flight path of the ball, making it ideal for range sessions or on-course analysis.
-
Comprehensive Ball Flight Data: Because they track the ball over a distance, radar units provide highly accurate carry distance, total distance, and apex height.
-
Club Data Capability: Many advanced radar units also track club head data (speed, path, face angle, angle of attack) by picking up signals from the club itself.
Cons:
-
Space Requirements (Indoor): This is the big one. To accurately track the ball's flight, radar systems need a significant amount of ball flight – often 10-15 feet (or more) – before the net or screen. In smaller indoor spaces, this can lead to less accurate spin data, as the radar has less time to "see" the ball spinning.
-
Potential for Interference: Metal objects or other electronic signals in close proximity can sometimes interfere with radar readings, though modern units are highly sophisticated at mitigating this.
Examples: Trackman 4, Rapsodo MLM2Pro (hybrid), FlightScope Mevo+
Camera-Based (Photometric) Launch Monitors: The Indoor Precision Kings
How they work: Photometric systems, like those from Foresight Sports and Uneekor, use high-speed cameras to capture a series of images of the golf ball and club head just before, during, and immediately after impact. By analyzing these images, they can determine ball speed, launch angle, spin rates, and often highly detailed club data.
Pros:
-
Ideal for Small Indoor Spaces: This is where photometric systems truly excel. They only need to "see" the ball and club for a few inches around impact. This makes them perfect for tight simulator setups, garages, or indoor studios where space is at a premium.
-
Highly Accurate Spin Data (Indoor): Since the cameras directly image the ball at impact, they provide incredibly accurate spin axis and spin rate measurements, regardless of how much ball flight space you have.
-
Detailed Club Data: Many camera systems are fantastic at capturing precise club data, including club path, face angle, and even impact location on the clubface, sometimes without the need for club stickers (e.g., Uneekor).
-
No Ball Markings (Often): Most photometric systems read the markings on a standard golf ball, meaning you don't need to use specially marked balls.
Cons:
-
Limited Outdoor Utility: While some camera systems can be used outdoors, their primary strength is indoor use. They don't track the full flight of the ball like radar, so you'll get less real-time feedback on dispersion and total distance outdoors.
-
Line of Sight: The cameras require a clear line of sight to the ball and club. This means precise placement is critical, and they can sometimes be more sensitive to lighting conditions.
Examples: Foresight GCQuad, GC3, Falcon, Uneekor EYE XO, EYE XO2, EYE XR, ProTee VX, SkyTrak+ (hybrid)
Hybrid Systems: Getting the Best of Both Worlds
Some newer launch monitors are incorporating both radar and camera technologies to leverage the strengths of each. The SkyTrak+ and Rapsodo MLM2Pro, for example, use photometric cameras for precise impact data and spin, combined with radar to enhance ball flight tracking, especially indoors or in tighter spaces. This hybrid approach aims to offer comprehensive data without the extensive space requirements of traditional radar units.
More to read
-
Blog post
Give your customers a summary of your blog post
12 Blog post
Give your customers a summary of your blog post
-
Blog post
Give your customers a summary of your blog post
12 Blog post
Give your customers a summary of your blog post
-
Blog post
Give your customers a summary of your blog post
12 Blog post
Give your customers a summary of your blog post
-
Blog post
Give your customers a summary of your blog post
12 Blog post
Give your customers a summary of your blog post